Sen. Lindsey Graham is helping draft a bipartisan federal media shield law to protect members of the press from their government. File photo
“Who is a journalist is a question we need to ask ourselves,” said U.S. Sen. Lindsey Graham, addressing reporters from the corner of his second-floor office on Hampton and Huger streets. “Is any blogger out there saying anything — do they deserve First Amendment protection? These are the issues of our times.”
Answers to those questions are what South Carolina’s senior U.S. senator wants to figure out as he helps draft a bipartisan federal media shield law to protect members of the press from their government. The Republican announced his plans to push such a bill during a May 29 news conference in his Columbia office. The legislation comes in response to criticism of a broad subpoena by the U.S. Justice Department of the phone records of Associated Press reporters and editors, and also a DOJ investigation into a Fox News reporter — a probe on which U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder personally signed off.
In both cases, the U.S. government was trying to sniff out how reporters received classified information. The scandals came around the same time the IRS was apologizing for targeting conservative groups that were applying for tax-exempt status. The convergence of scandals created a feeding frenzy in Washington, and political opponents of President Barack Obama smell blood in the water.
A media shield law died in Congress in 2009. Among other provisions, that law would have offered members of the media protection from having to testify in federal cases or from coughing up documents. On May 20, White House press secretary Jay Carney said Obama endorses the idea of a media shield law being taken up again by Congress.
South Carolina’s Graham is the lead GOP sponsor of the bill. He’s working with Democratic U.S. Sen. Chuck Schumer of New York and six other senators, three Democrats and three Republicans.
Graham didn’t give specifics on the law, but said it would make it more difficult for the government to get a reporter’s notes and strike the right balance between freedom of the press and protecting national security interests.
Asked how he’d determine whether someone is a journalist, Graham said it would likely take some revision of DOJ guidelines to make sure they’re up to date with current technology and the new media landscape. The DOJ hasn’t updated its guidelines about how it investigates reporters since the 1970s or ’80s, Graham said.
Only when it’s a matter of national security, Graham said, can the government get involved in journalism.
In 2009, when Congress last tried to hash out a media shield law, Clint Helder asked in Columbia Journalism Review, “Are journalists best defined by the act of reporting (what’s known as a functional definition), or by how they are employed (a status-based definition)?”
It’s a question Graham appears to be grappling with.
“You can sit in your mother’s basement and chat away, I don’t care. But when you start talking about classified programs, that’s when it gets to be important,” he said during a Free Times interview. “So, if classified information is leaked out on a personal website or [by] some blogger, do they have the same First Amendments rights as somebody who gets paid [in] traditional journalism?”
South Carolina has its own shield law for reporters. Graham voted for it as a member of the S.C. House when it passed decades ago.
The state law protects those who are engaged in the gathering and dissemination of news to the public, according to Jay Bender, the attorney for the state Press Association who lobbied for the bill.
“It could include a blogger — and it has,” Bender says. “Who among us can determine who is a reporter? In South Carolina we avoided that by focusing on persons and organizations engaged in gathering and the dissemination of news.”
New Downtown Dessert and Coffee Bar!
Tony’s Italian Eatery has teamed up with Southern Charm Sweets to bring you the highest quality dessert selection in the downtown area. 1120 Washington St., Suite 2. Find us on Facebook!
Make your own beer and wine!
Come get started on your “liquid hobby” and help us celebrate our 46th year in the Columbia area. Bet Mar Liquid Hobby Shop, 736 St. Andrews Road. Click to find out how!
Happy Hour and Sushi Specials All Week
Red Bowl in Lexington now has great early bird and late night sushi specials 7 days a week, as well as 99-cent kids meals on Saturdays! Click here for special information and hours.
Trustus Theatre Presents Evil Dead, The Musical
This musical version of Sam Raimi’s cult classic films promises to serve up more humor than horror. You can read more and purchase your tickets here.
A Healthy Happy Hour
4-7 p.m at Good Life Cafe on Main St. Try our $4 local draft beers, $4 organic wine, 1/2 off select bottles of house wine and $5 handcrafted house cocktails with juices cold pressed and made daily. Click here for more info.
Relaxation, Pain Management, and Stress Relief
Licensed massage therapist Allison Morris of AMR Massage is offering 50% off your first session and every 5th session free of charge. Click here for location, hours, and more information.
SEARCH FREE TIMES
Local restaurants serving locally grown food during Palmetto Tasty Tomato Restaurant Feast, July 11-18:
U.S. Security Associates
Now hiring immediately for armed and unarmed security officers. WE TRAIN YOU! Columbia & surrounding areas. ussecurityassociates.com
Real Estate Spotlight
Concord Park From the $150’s. Off 12th St. Extension. 803.419.2227. mungo.com
Click here for more real estate.
WATERFORD APARTMENTS 1 & 2 BR’s available with many amenities. Prime location, and plenty of space. Live large at Waterford Apartments. Bring in our ad in Free Times for $50 off your application fee. 1340 Longcreek Dr., Columbia, SC. Click here for more info.
ST. ANDREWS COMMONS APARTMENTS 1 & 2 BR’s available with many amenities. Close to everywhere YOU WANT TO BE! 1200 St. Andrews Rd., Columbia, SC. Click here for more info.
GABLE HILL APARTMENTS 1, 2 & 3 BR’s available with many amenities. Surround yourself with Southern comforts at Gable Hill Apartments! Bring in our ad in Free Times for $50 off your application fee. 310 Ross Rd, Columbia, SC. Click here for more info.
Donate Plasma Today & Be Somebody’s Hero For Life. You could earn up to $400 a month! Program and fees vary per location. Contact your local center today. 803-736-5888. Click here for more info