Two high-profile shooting cases in the Columbia area that have little in common other than geography and tragic collateral damage are generating concerns that South Carolina’s Stand Your Ground law, part of the Protections of Persons and Property Act, will turn Columbia into the Mogadishu of the Midlands, a free-fire zone.
The outcry has been seen on social media and in the comments sections of news websites, as well as in Kevin Fisher’s Oct. 16 City Watch column for Free Times, to the irritation of some attorneys we spoke to this week. They called the fears unfounded and born of limited legal knowledge.
The first case involved a father, Shannon Scott, who, according to The State’s John Monk, fatally shot an unarmed high school student as the boy sat alone in a parked car across the street. The father was responding to shots allegedly fired at or near his home by female students who had terrorized his daughter. Under Stand Your Ground, a judge granted the father immunity from prosecution because “he reasonably believed he was being attacked with deadly force directed at his home.”
Then, on Oct. 13 on Harden Street in Five Points, Michael Juan Smith, a 20- or 21-year-old black male, a felon, shot Martha Childress, a white freshman at the University of South Carolina. She was not his target, but she was paralyzed.
Shortly afterward, Fisher wrote: “When it comes to the thug who (allegedly) fired the shot, almost taking the life of 18-year-old Martha Childress and forever changing it, a recent and ridiculous South Carolina circuit court ruling could actually provide him a legal defense under the state’s Stand Your Ground law,” referring to the Scott case.
The Childress’ attorney, Joe McCulloch — who usually works as a defense attorney — called Free Times last week, echoing Fisher’s concern. He says the state legislature should remove Stand Your Ground language from the law and reassert the citizen’s duty to avoid provocation and retreat when possible and to employ proportionate force against a perceived threat — meaning one shouldn’t take a gun to a knife fight.
“There are a lot of people who believe that when they walk out of their front door or walk down Main Street that, if somebody threatens them, they ought to be allowed to kill them without any duty to try to avoid a problem,” McCulloch said.
Several other defense attorneys approached by Free Times scoffed at such a suggestion. Eventually, Luke Shealey, a former Richland County public defender now in private practice with considerable Stand Your Ground experience, agreed to address the matter on the record.
“It is a tragic situation but I don’t know if you can jump ahead and say, ‘This guy is going to get off scot-free because of Stand Your Ground, so we need to do away with Stand Your Ground,” he said, adding that George Zimmerman’s attorney’s never even employed Stand Your Ground in his defense in the Trayvon Martin case, despite all the media hype over it.
To Shealey, the two cases’ stark differences, which make a successful Stand Your Ground claim unlikely, are readily apparent: Scott was on his own property; Smith was partying in Five Points while unlawfully possessing a weapon. Scott heard a gunshot, reasonable indication he faced a deadly threat; Smith parent’s told the press that their son had been taunted.
The bottom line, Shealey says, is that guys carrying weapons around town unlawfully are not concerned with Stand Your Ground. “We should not as citizens, in my opinion, lose our fundamental right to protect ourselves because of a few bad apples that are highly publicized.”
Relaxation, Pain Management, and Stress Relief
Licensed massage therapist Allison Morris of AMR Massage is offering 50% off your first session and every 5th session free of charge. Click here for location, hours, and more information.
New Downtown Dessert and Coffee Bar!
Tony’s Italian Eatery has teamed up with Southern Charm Sweets to bring you the highest quality dessert selection in the downtown area. 1120 Washington St., Suite 2. Find us on Facebook!
Columbia’s Largest Sidewalk Sale
Shop local this tax free weekend! Devine Street and Five Points are teaming up for a massive sidewalk sale featuring great in-store specials from all your favorite retailers and a Saturday art stroll. Read more hereand here!
A Healthy Happy Hour
4-7 p.m at Good Life Cafe on Main St. Try our $4 local draft beers, $4 organic wine, 1/2 off select bottles of house wine and $5 handcrafted house cocktails with juices cold pressed and made daily. Click here for more info.
Tax-Free Weekend at Best Mattress
With big savings from July 31st-August 2nd, you can afford handcrafted quality. Free bed frame and pillows on any Full, Queen, or King set $599 and above! Click for locations and hours.
SEARCH FREE TIMES
U.S. Security Associates
Now hiring immediately for armed and unarmed security officers. WE TRAIN YOU! Columbia & surrounding areas. ussecurityassociates.com
Real Estate Spotlight
Concord Park From the $150’s. Off 12th St. Extension. 803.419.2227. mungo.com
Click here for more real estate.
WATERFORD APARTMENTS 1 & 2 BR’s available with many amenities. Prime location, and plenty of space. Live large at Waterford Apartments. Bring in our ad in Free Times for $50 off your application fee. 1340 Longcreek Dr., Columbia, SC. Click here for more info.
GABLE HILL APARTMENTS 1, 2 & 3 BR’s available with many amenities. Surround yourself with Southern comforts at Gable Hill Apartments! Bring in our ad in Free Times for $50 off your application fee. 310 Ross Rd, Columbia, SC. Click here for more info.
ST. ANDREWS COMMONS APARTMENTS 1 & 2 BR’s available with many amenities. Close to everywhere YOU WANT TO BE! 1200 St. Andrews Rd., Columbia, SC. Click here for more info.
Donate Plasma Today & Be Somebody’s Hero For Life. You could earn up to $400 a month! Program and fees vary per location. Contact your local center today. 803-736-5888. Click here for more info